AFA Alaska

Association of Flight Attendants-CWA Alaska Airlines Master Executive Council

Click here to report an issue to AFA
Menu
  • Local Councils
    • Anchorage (Council 30)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • Los Angeles (Council 18)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • Portland (Council 39)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • San Diego (Council 15)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • Seattle (Council 19)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • San Francisco (Council 35)
      • Officers
      • Committees

    • More About Local Councils >>
    Close
  • Master Executive Council
    • Officers
    • Close
  • Committees
      • Air Safety, Health, & Security (ASHSC)
        • Air Quality
      • Benefits
      • Communications
      • Employee Assistance Program & Professional Standards
      • Government Affairs
      • Grievance
      • Hotel
      • Human Rights
      • Inflight Service
      • Inflight Training
      • Membership
      • Reserve
      • Retirement
      • Scheduling
        • Pairing Construction
        • Preferential Bidding System (PBS)
      • Uniform

    • More About Committees >>
    Close
  • Contract
      • Contract Home
        • Current Contract
        • Ask Contract Questions
      • Contract Resources
        • Read Contract Q&A
        • Explanatory Videos
      • Contract Negotiations
        • 2019 Open Time Tentative Agreement
        • The Negotiating Process
        • 2014 Negotiating Committee
    • Close
  • Resources
      • Issues & Campaigns
        • Flight Attendant Fatigue
      • Newsroom
        • Industry News
      • Event Calendar
      • Membership Services
      • New Members
      • About
      • Links
      Close
    • Contact Us
    You are here: Home / Latest News / MEC Update September 26, 2013: ‘Night Rule’ Clarification and Concerns

    MEC Update September 26, 2013: ‘Night Rule’ Clarification and Concerns

    September 26, 2013 16:58

    Dear Flight Attendants,

     

    AFA has recently received a variety of questions and concerns with respect to Section 8.I in Hours of Service of our Collective Bargaining Agreement, or what’s commonly referred to as the “Night Rule.” It states the following:

     

    “If a Flight Attendant is on duty at 4 AM (except for an APSB who has not had a flying assignment prior to the APSB assignment during the same duty period), s/he will not be required to remain on duty beyond 8:30 AM. The Company many build single-duty period sequences with one (1) return to domicile outside these parameters, but the Flight Attendant will not be scheduled for additional flying after the return to domicile.”

    This language is important because it ensures that if you are on duty at 4AM (except when on a single duty period turn, i.e. SEA-ANC-SEA) you cannot be scheduled to remain on duty beyond 8:30AM. The language was incorporated into the contract in 2006 and was designed to address concerns with additional scheduled flying following an all-nighter.

    With the changeover from the former AOS pairing optimizer to the current Jeppesen pairing optimizer we started seeing pairings that have an additional leg following all-nighter flying. This was as early as July 2013. AOS was programmed to prohibit any additional flying if on duty at 4am. Jeppesen operates using a different algorithm that more closely mirrors the contractual language. Consequently, the Jeppesen solutions will contain sequences with a leg added to flying following an all-nighter. The only caveat is that these pairings must release prior to 8:30 AM as measured from the timezone of the initial departure station in that duty period. (More on that shortly.)

    Example: Seattle pairing #9695 from the August 2013 bid packet departs on day two from OGG at 10:15 PM Hawaii Standard Time (HST), lands in PDX at 6:22 AM Pacific Daylight Time (PDT) the following day and then departs to SFO and releases at 9:35 AM PDT. Days 1-3 of this 4-day pairing are illustrated below.

    Day 1

    867 SEA 18:20 OGG 21:15

    Day 2/3

    822 OGG 22:15 PDX 06:22

    244 PDX 07:35 SFO 09:20

    The reason this pairing is legal under the Night Rule is that the 8:30 AM release restriction is based on the time zone in which the duty period starts (i.e. the initial departure station time) and not local time. The release time is 9:35 AM PDT which is actually 6:35 AM HST (as Hawaii does not observe DST) and is therefore legal because release is before 8:30 AM HST.

    AFA is very much aware that the language is silent in regards to the time zone. Management asserted that they should not “lose” one or more hours of scheduling availability simply because a Flight Attendant is advancing through time zones by flying east. After extensive research into the bargaining history from that period we were able to confirm that it was not the intent of either party to apply additional “artificial” restrictions on the Night Rule due to changing time zones.

    Otherwise if the parties agreed that the Night Rule was based on local time, the opposite argument could be made. That is, management would gain one or more hours of scheduling availability if a Flight Attendant was flying west and obviously AFA is not going to agree to that interpretation. The reality is that the ability to create these types of pairings while complying with the Night Rule was not anticipated by either party in the mid-2000s.

    There are a variety of factors that have changed since those negotiations which have made it easier for the pairing optimizer to build this type of pairing:

    • Shorter block times, which allow for new combinations of segments to be legally scheduled within the 10 ½ hour duty day;

    • A dramatic increase in Hawaii flying; and

    • An expanded route structure with more flying across the system.

    When AFA first became aware that the new pairing optimizer was creating these types of pairings, a meeting was held between representatives from Alaska Airlines Scheduling & Planning and AFA. At that meeting AFA expressed concern that although the pairings were technically legal, additional scheduled flying following all-nighters was too hard on the crews working them.

    Management informed us of their intent to continue building these types of pairings. However, management did offer to voluntarily place some additional restrictions into the pairing optimizer:

    • No additional flying would be scheduled following an all-nighter on the last day of a sequence (so that a Flight Attendant would not be released to drive home at domicile after additional night flying); and

    • If an additional leg were to be scheduled following an all-nighter, the ground time would not exceed eighty nine (89) minutes.

    AFA continues to be concerned about the health and safety of the Flight Attendants working these trips due to fatigue. Despite the voluntary restrictions being in place for over a month now, it is clear they are not helping. The example pairing above is often hit with long ground times and block delays due to air traffic control (ATC) delays into SFO.

    We need assistance from Flight Attendants who are flying these trips or who have flown all-nighters in the past to send us feedback detailing the impacts to crews who are forced to fly under these conditions. The AFA Alaska Safety, Health and Security Committee (SHSC) is helping our effort by providing information regarding the overall impact of fatigue and the interruption of the circadian rhythm. However, having first-hand accounts from Flight Attendants will have the greatest impact in convincing management to change these pairings.

    Please send your comments to MEC Grievance Chair Jennifer Wise MacColl at jenwmac@comcast.net.

    In solidarity,

    Your MEC – Jeffrey Peterson, Terry Taylor, Yvette Gesch, Melanie Buker, Laura Masserant, Cathy Gwynn and Sandra Morrow; and MEC Grievance Chair Jennifer Wise MacColl

    “Five Bases, One Voice”

    alaskamec.org

    Print Friendly, PDF & Email

    Filed Under: Latest News

    Need Help?

    Have an issue or concern to report to AFA?  Click here to access the AFA Alaska online support center.

    Connect with Us on Facebook

    Connect with Us on Facebook

    Follow Us on Twitter

    Tweets by AFAAlaska

    Latest News

    • AFA Update – January 22, 2021
    • Safety of Our Crews, Our Flights and Our Country
    • Recurrent Training 2021
    • Council 35 News December 2020
    • End of Year Update
    • AFA Alaska Negotiations Update – December 17, 2020
    • AFA Update – December 11, 2020
    • Council 35 News – November 2020
    • AFA Update – November 20, 2020
    • AFA Alaska Update – November 12, 2020

    Latest News

    AFA Update – January 22, 2021

    January 22, 2021 12:00 Leave a Comment

    In This Edition Letters of Agreement and Memorandums of Understanding REMINDER: Reserve Availability & Commuting College Scholarship Opportunities Letters of Agreement and Memorandums of Understanding Grievance Committee Our Master Executive Council (MEC) occasionally enters into letters of agreement (LOAs) with management to address situations that were not anticipated or did not exist during contract negotiations.  The […]

    Safety of Our Crews, Our Flights and Our Country

    January 19, 2021 19:00 Leave a Comment

    Safety of Our Crews, Our Flights and Our Country Safety Of Our Crews Recent events are potentially negatively impacting effective Crew Resource Management The Master Executive Council (MEC) feels compelled to address the potentially negative impact to effective Crew Resource Management (CRM) resulting from the events most affecting the country over the past year: the […]

    Recurrent Training 2021

    January 13, 2021 17:00

    Recurrent Training 2021 Master Executive Council (MEC) + Inflight Training Committee + Air, Safety, Health and Security Committee (ASHSC) In This Edition Early Success Rates Look Promising COVID-19 Risk Mitigations Written Exam Practice Questions and Answers Adequate “Hands-On” Time Prior to Emergency Evacuation Evaluations Acceptable Deviations to Emergency Evacuation Commands Requalification Training (RQ) Early Success […]

    AFA Alaska Negotiations Update – December 17, 2020

    December 17, 2020 20:00

    AFA Alaska Negotiations Update – December 17, 2020 Master Executive Council In This Edition Updated Contract Negotiations Timeline Negotiations Delayed Until September 1, 2021 Overview of the Railway Labor Act Updated Contract Negotiations Timeline 1st round Negotiating Committee interviews – March & April 2020 Full pay scale increase of 2.5% – December 17, 2020 – […]

    AFA Update – December 11, 2020

    December 11, 2020 12:00

    In This Edition MEC Resolution on Gender Equality CALL CONGRESS: We’re Closer to #ReliefNow Than Ever Before Georgia Senate Runoff Election Community Resources for Those in Need MEC Resolution on Gender Equality Master Executive Council (MEC) AFA has long been a champion of equality both in and out of the workplace.  Over the course of many […]

    Top Posts & Pages

    • AFA Update – January 22, 2021
    • Contact Us
    • Contract
    • Aviation Safety Action Program (ASAP)
    • Seattle - Council 19
    • Retirement Committee
    • Links
    • Portland - Council 39
    • Master Executive Council (MEC)
    • Harvard Publication Regarding Past Uniform Reactions at Alaska

    Local Councils

    • Anchorage
    • Los Angeles
    • Portland
    • San Diego
    • San Francisco
    • Seattle

    Master Executive Council

    • MEC

    Contract

    • Contract Home

    Committees

    • Air Safety, Health, & Security
    • Benefits
    • Communications
    • EAP/Professional Standards
    • Government Affairs
    • Grievance
    • Hotel
    • Inflight Service
    • Reserve
    • Retirement
    • Scheduling
    • Uniform

    News By Month

    News By Category

    Air Quality Air Safety, Health, & Security Committee (ASHSC) Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) AS/VX Merger Benefits Committee Committees Communications Committee Contract Contract 2014 Negotiations Blog Contract 2021 Council 15 SAN Council 18 LAX Council 19 SEA Council 30 ANC Council 35 SFO Council 39 PDX EAP/Professional Standards Committee Featured Government Affairs Committee Grievance Committee Hotel Committee Human Rights Committee Industry News Inflight Service Committee Inflight Training Committee JNC Blog Latest News Local Councils Master Executive Council (MEC) Mobilization Committee Negotiations Pairing Construction Preferential Bidding System (PBS) Press Releases Reserve Committee Retirement Committee Scheduling Committee Uniform Committee
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

    Want To Stay In The Loop?

    The best way to stay connected with up-to-date AFA Alaska news and information is through a subscription to AFA Alaska emails!  Click the button below to sign up.  Already a subscriber?  You can make changes to your email by clicking below!
    Sign Up

    Connect With AFA

    • Contact Us
    • Online Support Center
    • AFA International
    • CWA
    • AFA Alaska Social Media Guidelines
    • AFA-CWA Mutual Respect Policy

    Copyright © 2013-2020 Alaska Airlines Master Executive Council, Association of Flight Attendants-CWA, AFL-CIO