AFA Alaska

Representing the Flight Attendants of Alaska + Hawaiian

Click here to report an issue to AFA
Menu
  • Local Councils
    • Anchorage (Council 30)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • Honolulu (Council 43)
    • Los Angeles (Council 18/pmAS)
      • Officers
      • Committees
      • Los Angeles (Council 47/pmHA)
        • Officers
      • Portland (Council 39)
        • Officers
        • Committees
      • San Diego (Council 15)
        • Officers
        • Committees
        • Seattle (Council 19)
          • Officers
          • Committees
        • San Francisco (Council 35)
          • Officers
          • Committees

        • More About Local Councils >>
        Close
      • Master Executive Council
        • Officers
        • Close
      • Committees
          • Air Safety, Health, & Security (ASHSC)
            • Air Quality
          • Benefits
          • Communications
          • Employee Assistance Program & Professional Standards
          • Government Affairs
          • Grievance
          • Hotel
          • Human Rights & Equity
          • Inflight Service
          • Inflight Training
          • Membership
          • Mobilization
          • Reserve
          • Retirement
          • Scheduling
            • Pairing Construction
            • Preferential Bidding System (PBS)
          • Uniform

        • More About Committees >>
        Close
      • Contract
          • Contract Home
            • 2025 Alaska TA2 (Ratified)
            • 2018 Alaska JCBA
            • 2020 Hawaiian Contract
            • Ask Contract Questions
          • Contract Resources
          • Alaska Contract Negotiations (2022-2025)
        • Close
      • Resources
          • What To Do If You Encounter Contaminated Cabin Air
          • Issues & Campaigns
          • Newsroom
            • AFA News Now
          • Event Calendar
          • Membership Services
          • New Members
          • About
          • Links
          Close
        • Merger
          • Joint Negotiating Committee
          • Close
        • Contact Us
        You are here: Home / Latest News / Payroll Error Results in a Signing Bonus of $3000 for Steps 15 and 16

        Payroll Error Results in a Signing Bonus of $3000 for Steps 15 and 16

        January 9, 2015 18:00

        Contractual grievance requested

         

        Recently a group of flight attendants sent a formal request to the Master Executive Council (MEC) seeking to file a contractual grievance. This is concerning the Company’s unintentional overpayment of the TA2 signing bonus to approximately 200 flight attendants. The request was filed in a timely manner but there seemed to be some confusion regarding the actual process., so here is a quick reminder.

        Individual flight attendants can file disciplinary grievances. Contractual grievances, however, may only be filed by AFA. It may be done on a domicile basis for individual flight attendants or for issues affecting a specific base. However, we typically file a grievance on the MEC level because the contract covers all flight attendants even when the particular incident affects only one flight attendant. Individual flight attendants or groups of flight attendants do not have the legal or contractual right to do so. [Note: Disregard struck text as this information is in error. See Important Correction to “Payroll Error Results in a Signing Bonus of $3000 for Steps 15 and 16” for more information.]

        Now the MEC would like to explain our decision whether or not to file the grievance as requested and to make sure you understand the dispute, the context in which it arose and our legal analysis.

        Background

         

        Management committed to pay every flight attendant a signing bonus upon ratification of TA2. Probationary flight attendants would receive $500 upon completion of probation; flight attendants who had completed probation and up to 17 years of “occupational service” (i.e. as an Alaska Airlines flight attendant) would receive $2,000; and flight attendants who had completed 17 or more years of occupational service would receive $3,000.

        Under our old contract, the top of scale was Step 17 at the completion of 17 years of occupational service. TA2 reduced the top of scale to the completion of fifteen years of occupational service (Step 15). When payroll began processing the signing bonuses, they realized some flight attendants who were at Step 15 or 16 actually had at least seventeen years of occupational service and should therefore receive the $3,000. (This unusual situation arose because these flight attendants were not credited with the 480 TFP per year required under the old contract to advance to the next pay step. TA2 eliminated that requirement.)

        In attempting to fix that problem, payroll inadvertently paid an additional $1000 signing bonus to not only the “480 hold-up” flight attendants but also to approximately 200 flight attendants, all of those at Step 15 and 16. When management discovered the error, they contacted AFA—on Christmas Eve. AFA fully expected management to initiate an overpayment correction. However, management was concerned that not only was it Christmas Eve but the 200 or so flight attendants might have already spent the money and could have believed that they were entitled to it.

        In discussing the issue further, AFA and management came to the conclusion that letting these flight attendants keep the money was consistent with earlier discussions between the MEC and management in regards to the signing bonus. You see, at one point AFA sought to have the $3000 signing bonus paid to all new top of scale flight attendants (i.e. Step 15 and above), but we were unsuccessful in our request. After some consideration, AFA and management orally agreed the Company would not seek to recover the additional $1,000 from these approximately 200 flight attendants on a non-precedential basis.

        Subsequent to that conversation, Vice President of Inflight Services Andy Schneider sent two different emails to the approximately 200 affected flight attendants. Andy informed them they could keep the $1000 overpayment/signing bonus. The details of those emails eventually found their way to social media and other public forums. This prompted concerns from some of the other flight attendants, who learned of it second-hand and out of context, which has led to the situation we face today.

         

        MEC Decision

         

        After consulting with both AFA Legal and our Collective Bargaining departments, the MEC is disinclined to file a contractual grievance over this issue. Here is why:

        1. TA2 clearly states that only flight attendants with 17 or more years of service will receive a $3,000 signing bonus. If we filed a grievance, management would grant it. But instead of awarding every other flight attendant an additional $1,000, management would likely then attempt to take the extra $1,000 back from the 200 affected flight attendants. We could continue the case to arbitration, but we believe that the arbitrator would enforce the Contract and side with management. Arbitrators routinely enforce clear and unambiguous language, and the law allows employers to recoup money erroneously paid to employees.
        2. Additionally, AFA’s oral agreement to allow the 200 flight attendants to keep the $1,000 is binding. We cannot legitimately file a grievance to rescind our own agreement. We would likely lose that case, along with our integrity. When management makes an agreement, we expect them to uphold it. In turn, they can and should expect the same from us.
        3. This is a tough case for the union because it necessarily pits members against members, with the leadership in the middle. We tried to do the right thing by the 200 flight attendants. Whether that was the right decision has certainly proved to be subject to debate. However, that decision was made, and we are standing by it.

        Summary

         

        The MEC recognizes timely communication was lacking and a full explanation of the circumstances would have been desirable. The MEC has learned a valuable lesson here and we will redouble our efforts to maintain open and forthright communications. If you have any additional questions or concerns, contact your Local Executive Council (LEC) president.

         

        In solidarity,

         

        Your MEC—Jeffrey Peterson, Brian Palmer, Yvette Gesch, Becky Strachan, Laura Masserant, Cathy Gwynn, Sandra Morrow and Stephen Couckuyt

        MEC 5B Logo

        Print Friendly, PDF & Email

        Filed Under: Latest News

        Need Help?

        Have an issue or concern to report to AFA?  Click here to access the AFA Alaska online support center.

        Latest News

        • Mahalo From Your AFA Hawaiian Communications Committee
        • Human Rights & Equity Committee Meeting Recap – 2nd Quarter 2025
        • AFA News in Review – June 13, 2025
        • Hotel Committee Meeting Recap – June 2025
        • Council 39 June 2025 Update
        • AFA Alaska News in Review – June 6, 2025
        • Celebrating LGBTQ Pride Month
        • AFA Alaska News in Review – May 30, 2025
        • Inflight Service Committee Meeting Recap – 2nd Quarter 2025
        • Scheduling Committee Meeting Recap – May 2025

        Mahalo From Your AFA Hawaiian Communications Committee

        June 19, 2025

        This message is for pre-merger Hawaiian Flight Attendants Aloha Hawaiian Flight Attendants, On behalf of your AFA Hawaiian Communications Committee, we would like to extend our heartfelt mahalo to each of you for your engagement and support throughout the years. It has been an honor to serve you and to help ensure that important communications […]

        Human Rights & Equity Committee Meeting Recap – 2nd Quarter 2025

        June 17, 2025

        On Thursday, June 12, our AFA Local Human Rights & Equity Committee Chairpersons met to discuss their ongoing activism to raise awareness and create positive change within our workplace and community. Your representatives attending the meeting included Louise Borras (pmAS LAX), Aaron Miller (PDX), Erika Daniel (SAN), and Freddy Vega (SEA). MEC Human Rights Committee […]

        Hotel Committee Meeting Recap – June 2025

        June 13, 2025

        This message is for pre-merger Alaska Flight Attendants Updated 06/13/2025 17:56 PT to remove a reference that indicated that there were no PVR layovers in July. There are in fact scheduled PVR layovers; these crews will be relocated to the crew hotel’s sister property. On Monday, June 9, our AFA Local Hotel Committee Chairpersons met […]

        Celebrating LGBTQ Pride Month

        June 1, 2025

        June 1 marks the beginning of LGBTQ Pride Month in the United States. This celebration originated to honor the Stonewall Uprising in Manhattan in 1969, a significant milestone in the LGBTQ civil rights movement. On June 28, 1970, the first Pride March was held in New York City to commemorate the first anniversary of the […]

        Inflight Service Committee Meeting Recap – 2nd Quarter 2025

        May 30, 2025

        This message is for pre-merger Alaska Flight Attendants On Thursday, May 15, our AFA Inflight Service Committee Chairpersons met to discuss their ongoing work to represent our Flight Attendants and push for improvements in our workplace. Representing you at the meeting were Naomi Parcell (ANC), Ross DeJong (SEA), Todd Horn (PDX), Raymond Ramirez (SFO), and […]

        RSS Negotiations News

        • State Sick Bank Implementation
        • Contract Implementation Update
        • Tentative Agreement Ratified
        • TA2: Four Days Left to Vote
        • TA2 Voting: How to Request a Replacement Activation Code
        • TA2 Voting is Now Open
        • TA2 Resource Recap
        • TA2 Virtual Q&A Recordings
        • TA2 Calculators Now Available
        • TA2 Updated Boarding Pay Comparison Resources

        Recent Posts

        • Mahalo From Your AFA Hawaiian Communications Committee
        • Human Rights & Equity Committee Meeting Recap – 2nd Quarter 2025
        • AFA News in Review – June 13, 2025
        • Hotel Committee Meeting Recap – June 2025
        • Council 39 June 2025 Update
        • AFA Alaska News in Review – June 6, 2025
        • Celebrating LGBTQ Pride Month
        • AFA Alaska News in Review – May 30, 2025
        • Inflight Service Committee Meeting Recap – 2nd Quarter 2025
        • Scheduling Committee Meeting Recap – May 2025

        Local Councils

        • Anchorage
        • Honolulu
        • Los Angeles (pre-merger Alaska)
        • Los Angeles (pre-merger Hawaiian)
        • Portland
        • San Diego
        • San Francisco
        • Seattle

        Master Executive Council

        • MEC

        Negotiations

        • Contract 2022 Home
        • Negotiations News
        • TA2 Information

        Contract

        • Contract Home

        Committees

        • Air Safety, Health, & Security
        • Benefits
        • Communications
        • EAP/Professional Standards
        • Government Affairs
        • Grievance
        • Hotel
        • Human Rights
        • Inflight Service
        • Mobilization
        • Reserve
        • Retirement
        • Scheduling
        • Uniform

        News By Month

        News By Category

        AFA News Now Air Quality Air Safety, Health, & Security Committee (ASHSC) Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) AS/HA Merger AS/VX Merger Benefits Committee Committees Communications Committee Contract Contract 2014 Negotiations Blog Council 15 SAN Council 18 LAX Council 19 SEA Council 30 ANC Council 35 SFO Council 39 PDX EAP/Professional Standards Committee Extension 2021 Blog Featured Government Affairs Committee Grievance Committee Hotel Committee Human Rights & Equity Committee Industry News Inflight Service Committee Inflight Training Committee JNC Blog Joint Negotiating Committee (JNC) Latest News Local Councils Master Executive Council (MEC) Membership Committee Message from the MEC President Mobilization Committee Negotiations Pairing Construction Preferential Bidding System (PBS) Press Releases Reserve Committee Retirement Committee Scheduling Committee Uniform Committee
        • Email
        • Facebook
        • Instagram
        • YouTube

        Want To Stay In The Loop?

        Stay up-to-date on AFA Alaska news and information by signing up for our email and text message updates. Click a button below to get started or update your preferences if you're already a subscriber.
        Sign Up for Emails
        Sign Up for Text Updates

        Connect With AFA

        • Contact Us
        • Online Support Center
        • AFA International
        • CWA
        • AFA Alaska Social Media Guidelines
        • AFA-CWA Mutual Respect Policy

        Copyright © 2013-2025 Alaska Airlines Master Executive Council, Association of Flight Attendants-CWA, AFL-CIO