AFA Alaska + Hawaiian

Representing the Flight Attendants of Alaska + Hawaiian

Click here to report an issue to AFA
Menu
  • Local Councils
    • Anchorage (Council 30)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • Honolulu (Council 43)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • Los Angeles (Council 18 pmAS)
      • Officers
      • Committees
      • Los Angeles/Seattle (Council 47 pmHA)
        • Officers
        • Committees
      • Portland (Council 39)
        • Officers
        • Committees
      • San Diego (Council 15)
        • Officers
        • Committees
        • Seattle (Council 19 pmAS)
          • Officers
          • Committees
        • San Francisco (Council 35)
          • Officers
          • Committees

        • More About Local Councils >>
        Close
      • Master Executive Council
        • Officers
        • Close
      • Committees
          • Air Safety, Health, & Security (ASHSC)
            • Air Quality
          • Benefits
          • Communications
          • Employee Assistance Program & Professional Standards
          • Government Affairs
          • Grievance
          • Hotel
          • Human Rights & Equity
          • Inflight Service
          • Inflight Training
          • Membership
          • Membership Engagement
          • Reserve
          • Retirement
          • Scheduling
            • Pairing Construction
            • Preferential Bidding System (PBS)
          • Uniform

        • More About Committees >>
        Close
      • Contract
          • Contract Home
            • 2025 Alaska Contract
            • 2025 Hawaiian Contract Extension
            • Ask Contract Questions
          • Contract Resources
          • Alaska Contract Negotiations (2022-2025)
        • Close
      • Resources
          • What To Do If You Encounter Contaminated Cabin Air
          • Issues & Campaigns
          • Newsroom
            • AFA News Now
          • Event Calendar
          • Membership Services
          • New Members
          • About
          • Links
          Close
        • Merger
          • Joint Negotiating Committee
          • Close
        • Contact Us
        You are here: Home / Latest News / MEC Grievance Update June 7, 2013: Washington Family Care Act (WFCA) Ruling

        MEC Grievance Update June 7, 2013: Washington Family Care Act (WFCA) Ruling

        June 7, 2013 16:45

        June 7, 2013

        Dear Flight Attendants,

        Another win for AFA and all Washington-based Flight Attendants! 

        On Friday, May 31, 2013, Judge Robart of the United States District Court for the Western District of Washington, ruled that the Railway Labor Act (RLA) did not preempt the Washington Family Care Act (WFCA) in Alaska Airlines v. Schurke, Case No. C11-0616JLR, Document 101. This is a very big deal with national ramifications. So how did we get here?

        Let’s start at the beginning.  Around the time that the former vice president of Inflight Services implemented her Sick Leave Improvement Plan, management also began cracking down on perceived abuses of our right to use our paid leave to care for sick family members.  They were assessing Emergency Drops (EDs)  if a Flight Attendant didn’t have enough sick leave to cover the absence. A number of Flight Attendants then filed charges with the Washington Department of Labor and Industries (L&I), alleging that Alaska had violated their rights under the Washington Family Care Act.  These cases were all settled.

        Meanwhile, Alaska Airlines management filed a federal lawsuit asserting that the RLA preempted the WFCA and therefore L&I could not enforce the Washington Family Care Act against the Company.  The court dismissed the case because there was no Flight Attendant who had actually been harmed by Alaska’s failure to follow the WFCA. Shortly thereafter Flight Attendant (and AFA Council 19 SEA President) Laura Masserant called in sick child for a trip.  She did not have enough sick leave to cover the sequence, so she asked to use her accrued vacation time.  Management refused, saying that bid vacation could not be used.  Laura filed with L&I, who ruled in her favor.

        Alaska Airlines management then did two things—it appealed the L&I order, and it re-filed the federal suit.  Management and L&I agreed to dismiss the appeal and concentrate on the lawsuit.  It was understood that the appeal would be reinstated if Alaska Airlines lost the case.

        This all happened late last fall.  AFA grew increasingly concerned that our voice wasn’t being heard in the lawsuit.  L&I was on our side, but as a government agency has its own interests which might not always be identical to ours.  We were also concerned about the parties settling, which would stick us with whatever outcome they reached.

        AFA International allocated significant financial resources to this case, allowing us to hire a legal expert in these matters: Seattle attorney Kathy Barnard.  She filed a motion to intervene (meaning to enter into a suit as a third party for one’s own interests) in the federal court case, which the judge granted.  Consequently, AFA officially became a party to the lawsuit with the right to file any necessary motions and be involved in any settlement talks.

        Earlier this year, the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment.  The court granted AFA and L&I’s motions and denied Alaska’s motion.  That is, we won the case without having to go to trial!

        Two things can happen now:  Alaska Airlines management can appeal the judge’s ruling to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals or it can forego that option and reinstate the appeal before L&I.  AFA is hoping that management gives up the fight against our rights under Washington law.  However, AFA would retain our intervenor status in a federal appeal and we would ask for such status in an appeal before L&I.

        So what does this all mean?  It means that Washington-based Flight Attendants continue to have the right to file charges with L&I if Alaska Airlines management violates their rights under the WFCA. Additionally, the federal court agreed with AFA and L&I that our WFCA rights exist separate from the collective bargaining agreement. It means that Alaska Airlines management must adhere to state law. Finally, it means that all of us stood up to Alaska Airlines management and its contracted legal help and kept our rights.

        Many thanks to AFA International and to Kathy Barnard and her team for their support. Congratulations to us all!

        In solidarity,

        Your MEC – Jeffrey Peterson, Terry Taylor, Yvette Gesch, Melanie Buker, Laura Masserant, Cathy Gwynn and Sandra Morrow

        MEC Grievance Chair Jennifer Wise MacColl and AFA Senior Staff Attorney Kimberley Chaput

        “Five Bases, One Voice”

        www.alaskamec.org

        References:

        Alaska Airlines v. Schurke, Case No. C11-0616JLR, Document 101

        Related

        Filed Under: Latest News

        Need Help?

        Have an issue or concern to report to AFA?  Click here to access the AFA Alaska online support center.

        Latest News

        • Council 47 LAX Base Update – LAX Membership Meeting – Don’t Forget
        • From Concept to Cabin: Putting Management’s Inflight Service Ideas Under the Microscope
        • Air Safety, Health and Security: Be Prepared For A Fume Event
        • AFA News in Review – November 13, 2026
        • Go In-Depth with Our AFA Inflight Service Committee Chairpersons
        • Council 47 Officer Update – ETCH Segment Trading and Pairing Reconstruction
        • 2027 Health Benefits Open Enrollment
        • Council 47 Officer Update – November 2026
        • Council 43 Update – December 2026 Bid Period
        • AFA Alaska + Hawaiian MEC Congratulates Pilots on Tentative Agreement

        From Concept to Cabin: Putting Management’s Inflight Service Ideas Under the Microscope

        November 16, 2026

        Welcome to Week 3 of our Inflight Service Committee Focus Month! Every day, we show up to create a warm, welcoming experience for our passengers while keeping safety as our top priority. High-quality service isn’t just part of the job; it’s a big part of who we are as Flight Attendants. But for service to […]

        Go In-Depth with Our AFA Inflight Service Committee Chairpersons

        November 13, 2026

        Whether you’re pushing a fully loaded cart down the aisle, organizing a packed galley, or delivering an overly complicated service on an extra-busy flight, every Flight Attendant has had that moment: glancing at the published service in the OSH and wondering, “Did anyone actually test this?” To shed light on what really happens behind the scenes, […]

        AFA Alaska + Hawaiian MEC Congratulates Pilots on Tentative Agreement

        November 11, 2026

        Yesterday, the Air Line Pilots Association (ALPA) announced that pilots at Alaska and Hawaiian Airlines have reached a Tentative Agreement (TA) for a new Joint Collective Bargaining Agreement (JCBA). On behalf of the AFA Alaska + Hawaiian Master Executive Council, we extend our congratulations to our flight deck colleagues and their negotiating committee on reaching […]

        Inside Our Inflight Service Committee Meetings With Management

        November 9, 2026

        Welcome to Week 2 of our Inflight Service Committee Focus Month! As aviation safety professionals and first responders, our primary focus in the cabin is always the safety and well-being of our passengers. At the same time, the care and hospitality we provide on every trip represent a core part of our professional identity. To […]

        Hotel Committee Meeting Recap – November 2026

        November 9, 2026

        On Monday, November 2, our AFA Hotel Committee Chairpersons met in-person to receive an update on current layover hotels and transportation providers and discuss concerns with management. Representing you at the meeting were Dori Marron (ANC), Brian Sherill (pmAS LAX), Le’a Tupola (pmHA LAX/SEA), Kelly Hepworth (PDX), Kanani Vallot (SAN), Hilary Streem (SFO), with MEC […]

        Recent Posts

        • Council 47 LAX Base Update – LAX Membership Meeting – Don’t Forget
        • From Concept to Cabin: Putting Management’s Inflight Service Ideas Under the Microscope
        • Air Safety, Health and Security: Be Prepared For A Fume Event
        • AFA News in Review – November 13, 2026
        • Go In-Depth with Our AFA Inflight Service Committee Chairpersons
        • Council 47 Officer Update – ETCH Segment Trading and Pairing Reconstruction
        • 2027 Health Benefits Open Enrollment
        • Council 47 Officer Update – November 2026
        • Council 43 Update – December 2026 Bid Period
        • AFA Alaska + Hawaiian MEC Congratulates Pilots on Tentative Agreement
        • Inside Our Inflight Service Committee Meetings With Management
        • Hotel Committee Meeting Recap – November 2026
        • 787-10 New Aircraft Negotiations
        • AFA News in Review – November 6, 2026
        • MEC Retirement Committee Chairperson Interviews – December 2026

        Local Councils

        • Anchorage
        • Honolulu
        • Los Angeles (pre-merger Alaska)
        • Los Angeles/Seattle (pre-merger Hawaiian)
        • Portland
        • San Diego
        • San Francisco
        • Seattle (pre-merger Alaska)

        Master Executive Council

        • MEC

        Contract

        • Contract Home

        Committees

        • Air Safety, Health, & Security
        • Benefits
        • Communications
        • EAP/Professional Standards
        • Government Affairs
        • Grievance
        • Hotel
        • Human Rights
        • Inflight Service
        • Membership Engagement
        • Reserve
        • Retirement
        • Scheduling
        • Uniform

        News By Month

        News By Category

        AFA News Now Air Quality Air Safety, Health, & Security Committee (ASHSC) Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) AS/HA Merger AS/VX Merger Benefits Committee Committees Communications Committee Contract Contract 2014 Negotiations Blog Council 15 SAN Council 18 LAX (pmAS) Council 19 SEA (pmAS) Council 30 ANC Council 35 SFO Council 39 PDX Council 43 HNL Council 47 LAX/SEA (pmHA) EAP/Professional Standards Committee Extension 2021 Blog Featured Government Affairs Committee Grievance Committee Hotel Committee Human Rights & Equity Committee Industry News Inflight Service Committee Inflight Training Committee JNC Blog Joint Negotiating Committee (JNC) Latest News Local Councils Master Executive Council (MEC) Membership Engagement Committee Message from the MEC President Mobilization Committee Negotiations Pairing Construction Preferential Bidding System (PBS) Press Releases Reserve Committee Retirement Committee Scheduling Committee Uniform Committee
        • Email
        • Facebook
        • Instagram
        • YouTube

        Want To Stay In The Loop?

        Stay up-to-date on AFA Alaska + Hawaiian news and information by signing up for our email and text message updates. Click a button below to get started or update your preferences if you're already a subscriber.
        Sign Up for Emails
        Sign Up for Text Updates

        Connect With AFA

        • Contact Us
        • Online Support Center
        • AFA International
        • CWA
        • AFA Alaska + Hawaiian Social Media Guidelines
        • AFA-CWA Mutual Respect Policy

        Copyright © 2013-2026 Alaska/Hawaiian Airlines Master Executive Council, Association of Flight Attendants-CWA, AFL-CIO