AFA Alaska

Representing the Flight Attendants of Alaska + Hawaiian

Click here to report an issue to AFA
Menu
  • Local Councils
    • Anchorage (Council 30)
      • Officers
      • Committees
    • Honolulu (Council 43)
    • Los Angeles (Council 18/pmAS)
      • Officers
      • Committees
      • Los Angeles (Council 47/pmHA)
        • Officers
      • Portland (Council 39)
        • Officers
        • Committees
      • San Diego (Council 15)
        • Officers
        • Committees
        • Seattle (Council 19)
          • Officers
          • Committees
        • San Francisco (Council 35)
          • Officers
          • Committees

        • More About Local Councils >>
        Close
      • Master Executive Council
        • Officers
        • Close
      • Committees
          • Air Safety, Health, & Security (ASHSC)
            • Air Quality
          • Benefits
          • Communications
          • Employee Assistance Program & Professional Standards
          • Government Affairs
          • Grievance
          • Hotel
          • Human Rights & Equity
          • Inflight Service
          • Inflight Training
          • Membership
          • Membership Engagement
          • Reserve
          • Retirement
          • Scheduling
            • Pairing Construction
            • Preferential Bidding System (PBS)
          • Uniform

        • More About Committees >>
        Close
      • Contract
          • Contract Home
            • 2025 Alaska TA2 (Ratified)
            • 2018 Alaska JCBA
            • 2020 Hawaiian Contract
            • Ask Contract Questions
          • Contract Resources
          • Alaska Contract Negotiations (2022-2025)
        • Close
      • Resources
          • What To Do If You Encounter Contaminated Cabin Air
          • Issues & Campaigns
          • Newsroom
            • AFA News Now
          • Event Calendar
          • Membership Services
          • New Members
          • About
          • Links
          Close
        • Merger
          • Joint Negotiating Committee
          • Close
        • Contact Us
        You are here: Home / Negotiations / Extension 2021 Blog / Does a Contract Extension Make Sense Right Now?

        Does a Contract Extension Make Sense Right Now?

        April 29, 2021 09:45

        Does a Contract Extension Make Sense Right Now?

        (Compiled from the 2nd virtual roadshow transcript and lightly edited.)

        Q According to an economist at Morgan Stanley I talked with about a month ago, this pandemic produced what is called an exogenous shock to the economy, which typically produces immediate chaos but a short recession and quick recovery. In this case that is what is happening: The US economy bottomed out last July, corporate profits reached pre-pandemic levels Q1 2021, and corporate revenues are on track to do so by June 2021. Employment always takes longer to recover. The airline industry will lag but will also recover.

        Since the contract negotiations will take several years, and I’ve read that the pay part of negotiations happens at the end, we should be well into recovery by the time our pay is negotiated. Without this extension our prior contract already has been extended. Many Flight Attendants don’t believe another extension makes sense. Can the economist comment on this?

        A

        Yes, the economist can. First off, I don’t know which corporations are operating at pre-pandemic levels of profitability in the first quarter of 2021.Obviously airlines aren’t, and I guess the question really is in terms of the next year following the amendable date without a TA the difference between 1.5% and 0% is kind of what we’re looking at.

        So, when I when I say that I mean we are not going to get that money back in a future year by saying we gave it up, (but) we want it back in 2023 or 2024. It’s kind of a lost opportunity in my book. To look at with the contract opening in December of 2021where would we be in a year if we didn’t extend, and I would say we would have gotten zero percent pay increases for sure as opposed to a 1.5 percent pay increase for sure.

        So, I agree that the airline industry lags behind the rest of the economy. The economy is forecast to grow very strong coming out of this recession, but I do think it’s really a question of do you want a one and a half percent pay raise or a zero percent pay raise over the next year after the amendable date. That’s really the question on the table because I don’t think there’s any way to negotiate this money back in some future period to make up for what we gave up.

        Aviation Economist Dan Akins – FlightPath Economics, LLC

        Almost every section of the agreement has an economic impact, and when you’re bargaining, if the company is really in cash preservation mode, then even sections you wouldn’t think like sick leave and vacation–any little work rule improvement that you want there–they’re looking at how is that going to impact on sick leave rates, how it’s going to impact on vacation utilization and so forth. In that context what you find once you get into scheduling and reserve, they’re looking at all of those work rules that you wouldn’t necessarily think as economic items as well. So, in the context where a company is either concerned about cash burn or they’re concerned about rebuilding cash reserves, all of the sections of the contract become a lot more difficult to negotiate, and things really slow down.

        In part we know the answer here because we know that negotiations were proceeding at a pace such as (at) American and Southwest. Even though they…already started their negotiations, those negotiations essentially stalled out. Even though they weren’t at (the) economics (yet), just because there wasn’t going to be or there wasn’t any progress being made. When there [were] substantive discussions, the company was coming in and demanding concessions.

        So, the other thing I think to take into account is Jeff went over your position in the industry [regarding pay ray rates earlier in the roadshow], and … one of the features of bargaining in this industry is we do something called “leapfrog bargaining.” What that means is we’re able to win increases at one carrier that provides a platform for the next Flight Attendant group to come back and use those increases as an argument about why they need more.

        So, for example the Hawaiian Flight Attendants got an increase right before the pandemic. Those negotiations centered on where was everyone else situated, and we had a big fight with [Hawaiian management]. It was really based on what the comparators in the industry, and how does that affect our negotiations. One of the difficulties if you try to speed up your negotiations in front of everybody else is that your comparators haven’t had a chance to get the increases that they normally would have gotten. American you know we would have hoped but for the pandemic that they would have been in a better place right now with their contract. If they had gotten some good increases, that provides a better basis for you to get increases and so forth. United, Spirit and all of that.

        You want to be … doing your timing correctly … in order to get the increases … that you really want in these negotiations. We need some of these other work groups to get in there and also be fighting for increases otherwise you’re going to be a little bit ahead of the curve.

        This one-and-a-half percent, it’s basically in line when you do an extension. You don’t get a massive increase, but you get something to kind of keep you where you’re at until you can have a more favorable point.

        AFA Director of Collective Bargaining Joe Burns

        From my experience with negotiating for AFA Alaska, it’s exactly like what Joe has been saying about what Flight Attendant might think is not economic because it’s not specifically having to do with the step rate–so the pay rate–or say the vacation value or something like that. They think that’s not economic, all the other things, but they actually are…. Say open time is an example of something that we may want to likely revisit, and it does have an economic impact because … it does impact staffing, and therefore it costs the company money…. A sensitive topic that we will address at some point is say TFP versus block, and there’s a whole conversation that could be had on that, but … again it’s an economic conversation.

        So, if we didn’t delay, (then) we would go to the table [in September], and we would quickly blaze through the non-discrimination (policy), all the stuff that we agree to right away, or the very low-lying things about certain definitions or updating and incorporating LOAs that we’ve already agreed to into the contract.

        Once we’re done with that, then it really is like all of it is economic: reserve, scheduling, hours of service, obviously pay, vacation, sick leave. So, it would just make it challenging to have those conversations and probably would not be extremely productive for some period of time, and that’s why we have brought it to you guys for consideration whether this is our best strategic position to enter negotiations [in September or to extend for a year].

        MEC President Jeff Peterson
        Print Friendly, PDF & Email

        Filed Under: Extension 2021 Blog, Latest News, Negotiations Tagged With: 2021, blog, contract, Extension, TA

        Need Help?

        Have an issue or concern to report to AFA?  Click here to access the AFA Alaska online support center.

        Latest News

        • AFA News in Review – October 10, 2025
        • SEA Domicile Negotiations – October 2025
        • Protecting Yourself From Drug-Facilitated Sexual Assault
        • Government Affairs Committee Update – 4th Quarter 2025
        • Air Safety, Health, & Security Committee Meeting Recap – 4th Quarter 2025
        • AFA News in Review – October 3, 2025
        • Joint Contract Negotiations Session 7 – September 2025
        • Refreshed Inflight Mobile Device (IMD) Distribution
        • AFA News in Review – September 26, 2025
        • Scheduling Committee Meeting Recap – September 2025

        SEA Domicile Negotiations – October 2025

        October 9, 2025

        The recent meetings of the SEA Domicile Negotiating Committee in Seattle and Honolulu highlighted both progress and persistent challenges in negotiations with management. While there has been advancement on some issues, significant concerns remain. Key topics under discussion include the transfer processes, return options to HNL or LAX, staffing, moving expenses, and safeguarding existing bases. Our committee prepares for the next round of negotiations in Seattle during the week of October 20.

        Protecting Yourself From Drug-Facilitated Sexual Assault

        October 8, 2025

        Understanding Drug-Facilitated Sexual Assault (DFSA) Drug-facilitated sexual assault (DFSA) involves the use of substances to incapacitate someone, making them vulnerable to sexual assault. These substances are often undetectable, having no color, taste, or smell, and can be easily added to drinks. Common Drugs Used in DFSA Important Note: Alcohol significantly enhances the effects of these drugs, […]

        Government Affairs Committee Update – 4th Quarter 2025

        October 7, 2025

        An update on what our Government Affairs Committee has been working on this quarter. Thank you to all our Members who remain engaged and to all our volunteers and Committee Members for dedicating their time representing our Members, advocating for the safety and advancement of our careers while strengthening our labor movement every single day […]

        Air Safety, Health, & Security Committee Meeting Recap – 4th Quarter 2025

        October 6, 2025

        This message is for pre-merger Alaska Flight Attendants On Thursday, October 2, our AFA Local Air Safety, Health, & Security Committee (ASHSC) Chairpersons met to discuss their ongoing work to represent our Flight Attendants and push for improvements in our workplace. Representing you at the meeting were Deb Wallstrom (ANC), David Lake (SEA), Kalin Lackey […]

        Joint Contract Negotiations Session 7 – September 2025

        October 3, 2025

        Our JNC made significant progress in shaping our JCBA, successfully reaching a Tentative Agreement on Section 13 – Uniforms. Key provisions include enhancements to uniform standards, ensuring protective measures such as no surnames on name tags from the Hawaiian CBA. While we continue discussions on various sections, including Air Safety Health and Security, Training, and Commuter Policy. We appreciate feedback from the 2207 Flight Attendants who participated in our recent Vacation Survey.

        Recent Posts

        • AFA News in Review – October 10, 2025
        • SEA Domicile Negotiations – October 2025
        • Protecting Yourself From Drug-Facilitated Sexual Assault
        • Government Affairs Committee Update – 4th Quarter 2025
        • Air Safety, Health, & Security Committee Meeting Recap – 4th Quarter 2025
        • AFA News in Review – October 3, 2025
        • Joint Contract Negotiations Session 7 – September 2025
        • Refreshed Inflight Mobile Device (IMD) Distribution
        • AFA News in Review – September 26, 2025
        • Scheduling Committee Meeting Recap – September 2025
        • Meet Our Pre-Merger Alaska Committee Chairperson & Representatives
        • Inflight Service Committee Meeting Recap – 3rd Quarter 2025
        • Vacation Survey Closing Soon
        • Meet Our Merged MEC Committee Chairpersons
        • Human Rights & Equity Committee Meeting Recap – 3rd Quarter 2025

        Local Councils

        • Anchorage
        • Honolulu
        • Los Angeles (pre-merger Alaska)
        • Los Angeles (pre-merger Hawaiian)
        • Portland
        • San Diego
        • San Francisco
        • Seattle

        Master Executive Council

        • MEC

        Negotiations

        • Contract 2022 Home
        • Negotiations News
        • TA2 Information

        Contract

        • Contract Home

        Committees

        • Air Safety, Health, & Security
        • Benefits
        • Communications
        • EAP/Professional Standards
        • Government Affairs
        • Grievance
        • Hotel
        • Human Rights
        • Inflight Service
        • Mobilization
        • Reserve
        • Retirement
        • Scheduling
        • Uniform

        News By Month

        News By Category

        AFA News Now Air Quality Air Safety, Health, & Security Committee (ASHSC) Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) AS/HA Merger AS/VX Merger Benefits Committee Committees Communications Committee Contract Contract 2014 Negotiations Blog Council 15 SAN Council 18 LAX Council 19 SEA Council 30 ANC Council 35 SFO Council 39 PDX EAP/Professional Standards Committee Extension 2021 Blog Featured Government Affairs Committee Grievance Committee Hotel Committee Human Rights & Equity Committee Industry News Inflight Service Committee Inflight Training Committee JNC Blog Joint Negotiating Committee (JNC) Latest News Local Councils Master Executive Council (MEC) Membership Committee Membership Engagement Committee Message from the MEC President Mobilization Committee Negotiations Pairing Construction Preferential Bidding System (PBS) Press Releases Reserve Committee Retirement Committee Scheduling Committee Uniform Committee
        • Email
        • Facebook
        • Instagram
        • YouTube

        Want To Stay In The Loop?

        Stay up-to-date on AFA Alaska news and information by signing up for our email and text message updates. Click a button below to get started or update your preferences if you're already a subscriber.
        Sign Up for Emails
        Sign Up for Text Updates

        Connect With AFA

        • Contact Us
        • Online Support Center
        • AFA International
        • CWA
        • AFA Alaska Social Media Guidelines
        • AFA-CWA Mutual Respect Policy

        Copyright © 2013-2025 Alaska Airlines Master Executive Council, Association of Flight Attendants-CWA, AFL-CIO